CHRISTIAN COMIC ARTS SOCIETY :: A NETWORK OF CHRISTIAN FELLOWSHIP FOR COMICS FANS, PROS, AND AMATEURS

You need to be a member of CCAS - Christian Comic Arts Society to add comments!

Join CCAS - Christian Comic Arts Society

Comments

  • I just emailed you my critique

  • WOW! Thanks so much for the advice! 

    I love the advice about Barook! I didn't think about that and it's super helpful. 

    I appreciate the ETD comment, as I read it over it wasn't really explained how he knew. 

    Also, The Deal-Maker will end up not being the top dog. So I think I will keep him where he was at. But I appreciate, again, the details about crime bosses. I knew that a little but that was very helpful.

    Also the Deal-Maker's compulsion to make deals is just like the Riddler's compulsion to make riddles.    

  • As a fan and an amateur artist, there are several things I like about your script: The dialogue is crisp the characters are interesting. Your script reflects a practice style.

    3 page prologue is a nice start, but Nighthawk needs to get something out of the conflict besides a dead stooge. Either Barock needs to reveal info to her in a fit of overconfidence or she needs to get some bit of sought after info off of his body, otherwise she doesn't profit from his death.

    Main story: flows smoothly, maintains interest. Continue to develop hers and her assistant's personalities with small personal tidbits in the dialogue, you want us to care about them. I hope the 1:38am ETD was a joke, unless there was a witness to the killing. The estimate of height and weight was explained nicely, distance between shoe prints can allow police to estimate height and leg-length. Shoe wear patterns can be as distinct as finger prints for identifying a serial killer.

       According to several Villain training books and a Mafia Union manual, a kingpin shouldn't be doing his own killing.  If Deal Maker is a long term crime boss, he will be more threatening if you keep him in the shadows for a while and let Nighthawk wrestle with his sub-bosses.

       These are just my quick thoughts, please disagree or use them as you see fit. 

This reply was deleted.